As
of late September 2003, according to the head of Israeli
military intelligence, Maj.-Gen. Zeevi-Farkash, orders
for terrorist attacks were actually coming directly from
Arafat's headquarters.
As early as 1997, Arafat authorized Hamas
and Islamic Jihad attacks; he formed an umbrella group
together with these Islamists organizations called the
"Nationalist and Islamic Forces" that coordinated
attacks against Israel, during the recent intifada, under
the leadership of Fatah.
Arafat finances suicide bombings; he has
paid operatives, while his office has funded explosive
materials, manufactured locally or imported from abroad,
like in the case of Iran.
Arafat actually commands the Al-Aqsa Martyrs
Brigades, which has taken a leading role in shooting incidents
and bombing attacks against Israeli civilians. As the
mastermind of the second Palestinian intifada of September
2000, according to Palestinian sources, his influence
over the scope and timing of the violence is extensive
and even decisive.
Orders for Terrorist Attacks Come from
Arafat's HQ
Yasser Arafat's record of not fighting terror was a cause
of concern and consternation for the Israeli military
soon after the Oslo Accords were signed in 1993. When
Arafat entered the Gaza Strip in 1994, he already smuggled
two PLO operatives with their weapons inside his Mercedes
limousine. In 1998, Maj.-Gen. Moshe Ya'alon, then head
of military intelligence, noted: "Sadly, I cannot
say that at any point since it entered the territory,
in May 1994, that the Palestinian Authority acted decisively
and in a clear-cut way against the terrorist operational
capability of Hamas, as well as Islamic Jihad."
On September 28, 2003, military intelligence
head Maj.-Gen. Aharon Zeevi-Farkash disclosed that orders
for terrorist attacks are still emanating from Yasser
Arafat's Ramallah compound. While not saying that Arafat
himself is ordering terrorist attacks, it is extremely
unlikely that these communications for operations against
Israelis would be permitted without Arafat's knowledge
and approval.
The international community has been debating
the Israeli Cabinet's decision to remove Arafat. A broad
international consensus has arisen that Arafat is an obstacle
to peace. Even France's President Jacques Chirac recently
said, "Arafat is responsible for the failure, for
all the failures, because he always wanted a little more."
Nonetheless, it is far less accepted that Arafat, in fact,
is personally responsible for much of the ongoing terrorism.
It is imperative that Israel's moves against
Arafat be seen against the backdrop of cumulative acts
that he has committed, and not just omissions in complying
with his commitments to fight terrorism. Should Israel
actually move against Arafat, let us understand the reasons
for such action:
Arafat Authorized Hamas and Islamic
Jihad Attacks
During March 9-13, 1997 (and perhaps earlier), Arafat
met personally in Gaza with the leaders of Hamas and other
militant groups, and gave them the "green light"
to resume terrorist attacks. Following those meetings,
Chief of Staff Lt.-Gen. Amnon Lipkin-Shahak told Israel
Radio on March 23, 1997: "Organizations such as Hamas
and Islamic Jihad have an understanding from the Palestinian
Authority to carry out attacks." After the outbreak
of the violence in September 2000, Hamas, Islamic Jihad,
and Fatah coordinated together under the umbrella of the
"Nationalist and Islamic Forces," led by Fatah.
Arafat Finances Suicide Bombings
In a memorandum captured in Operation Defensive Shield,
the Secretary-General of the Fatah office in Tulkarm requested
that Arafat provide $2,000 to each of 15 specifically
named "Fighting Brethren" of the Tanzim military
wing of Fatah. According to Israeli military sources,
each of the "fighters" was involved in the planning
or execution of suicide attacks. With his own signature
in Arabic, Arafat authorized the payment of $800 to each
of the "fighters" on April 5, 2001.
Arafat Finances Terrorist Attacks
On September 19, 2001, Arafat
personally approved a request for payment of $600 to three
people including Ra'ad Karmi, commander of the Tanzim
in Tulkarm, who was personally involved in at least 25
shooting attacks against Israelis. Arafat funded Karmi
even though Israel had placed Karmi on its "most-wanted"
list just three months earlier. On the same day, Arafat
approved payment to Amar Qadan, a member of his own Force-17
"Presidential Guard," who was involved in terrorist
operations.
A second request was faxed to Arafat to
fund 12 more terrorists. According to Colonel Miri Eisin
of the IDF Intelligence Branch, "Every single one
of them was on our wanted list...these are Tanzim members,
which is Arafat's own party." Arafat knew well that
these individuals were involved in terrorism. Nevertheless,
on January 7, 2002, "Arafat himself - in his handwriting,
with his signature...agreed to pay the money."
On January 17, 2002, two and a half weeks
later, a Palestinian killed six Israelis and wounded twenty-six
at a bat-mitzvah party in Hadera, initiated and planned
by one of those on Arafat's list Mansur Saleh Sharim,
who was already responsible for the deaths of at least
three Israelis. Senior Fatah figures in Israeli custody,
like Marwan Barghouti, admitted subsequently that Arafat
approved funding for Fatah operatives with the knowledge
that it would be used to finance terrorist attacks against
Israeli civilians.
Arafat Commands the Al-Aqsa Martyrs
Brigades
While some draw a distinction between Yasser Arafat's
Fatah organization and the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, Palestinians
refute such assertions. The leader of the Al-Aqsa Martyrs
Brigades in Tulkarm told USA Today in March 2002: "The
truth is, we are Fatah, but we didn't operate under the
name of Fatah....We are the armed wing of the organization.
We receive our instructions from Fatah. Our commander
is Yasser Arafat himself."
In the early months of 2002, the number
of attacks by the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, including
suicide bombings, exceeded those of Hamas and Islamic
Jihad. On September 16, 2001, the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades
requested payment to cover expenses for "production
of explosive charges" from Arafat's financial confidante,
Fuad Shubaki, who, as the head of the Palestinian Authority's
"Armed Forces Financial Directorate," was also
the mastermind behind the Karine-A weapons ship delivery
from Iran. That ship also carried huge amounts of C-4
explosives that could only be used for bombing attacks
against Israel.
Arafat has been a participant in, and
supreme commander of, many of the Palestinians' terror
activities. He has knowingly funded terrorists, both before
and after they committed crimes. He has authorized plans
for terror actions. What Israel has put together on Arafat's
involvement in terrorism is only the tip of the iceberg;
these are only the connections that have been documented
in captured materials. As the mastermind of the entire
September 2000 intifada, his impact has been far more
widespread. Even though he had committed at Oslo to "put
an end to decades of confrontation and conflict...and
strive to live in peaceful coexistence, mutual dignity
and security," Arafat's actions over the past decade
have proven the opposite.
On September 19, 2003, the UN General
Assembly met in Emergency Special Session and adopted
a resolution demanding that Israel "desist from any
act of deportation and to cease any threat to the safety
of the elected President of the Palestinian Authority."
The UN resolution derives its legal basis from international
humanitarian law in general, and the 1949 Geneva Convention
Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time
of War (Fourth Geneva Convention). But if Arafat is not
just a civilian heading a government, but is actually
directing and financing military activities and terrorist
attacks against Israeli civilians, he loses any protection
afforded him by international law.
Eli Kazhdan is a senior researcher
at the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs. He served
as foreign policy advisor to Minister Natan Sharansky.
This Jerusalem Issue Brief was prepared with the assistance
of David Keyes.
|